oloriel: (tolkien - not nice but true)


[livejournal.com profile] dawn_felagund has summed up pretty much exactly what I think about the topic, so I am - hurrah! - no longer feeling the need to put my thoughts into words. I'll merely quote her:

Let's be frank, folks. If critique of a policy, no matter how heated, was what caused a fandom institution to close its doors, then it wasn't long for the world anyway. I say this as an admin and, again, with the recognition that you have to expect these kinds of problems, and you either deal or you don't. There's certainly nothing wrong with reaching the point where you can't or won't deal anymore, but pretending like an otherwise healthy and thriving fandom institution came suddenly crashing to the ground because of a critique over a ratings policy would be laughably ridiculous if I hadn't seen so much finger-pointing to this effect.

THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS. Signed a dozen times.
(Her full, thoughtful and intelligent entry can be found here. It says everything I might want to say on the matter - only better, and providing background explanation I wouldn't even have thought of.)

(Actually, I might want to say more on the matter, but that would leave the territory of reasonable and diplomatic discourse. So I shall hold my tongue. Unless anything comes up in the comments to this entry here, of course. ;))
oloriel: (Og thinks you missed the point)


*snickers*

In Tolkien - specifically, Silmarillion - fanfic, there's a sort of movement that strives to explain the originally mythological goings-on and/or backgrounds in other ways, mostly natural science. Sometimes this results in really awesome stories and thought experiments while sometimes I dislike it because it deconstructs things just a bit too much for my taste. Kinda like in real life, really: If it gets too deconstructive, I'm off...
Anyway, among the MEFA nominees is OMG SOMETHING SPOILERIFIC IF YOU HAVEN'T READ 'ON THE TWILIT PLANET BELOW' YET! )

(I thought I'd never get to use this icon. Finally! Finally! >:D)

- - -
In more productive news, I cut all the reeds in our constructed wetland (thank you, [livejournal.com profile] al_pha!), because that's what you have to do in autumn to keep it nice and orderly and growing back next spring, or something. Most of the reeds I used as mulch for the garden, but some I kept to try making skeps later on. No, I won't use skeps on my real bees, but they'll be cool to have for LARP events. Remember, guys, it's all fun and games as long as it only happens to fictional people! Or bees, as the case may be.
oloriel: (let it bee)


This night, Felix slept almost six hours in one piece. I'm almost rested!

Unfortunately, I still have a headache from the day before yesterday, when Felix was very unhappy and fussy and had to be either carried around or nursed all the time and still often didn't stop crying. (I was running around pretty much in Minoan court fashion all day because there was just no point in covering up :P) The headache is the sort of headache that comes from a stiff neck. Yesterday my legs also hurt something awful, but at least they are back to normal now. Either it was the walking around/ sitting uncomfortably, or the cold that's been going around at Jörg's workplace and that he may well have handed down to me. Or us, come to think of it - Felix has been coughing a few times in the past days, and sometimes breathed as though his respiratory tract was partially blocked. And he was, as I said, pretty unhappy and peevish. Poor little man, and of course the crying and the lack of sleep gets to us grown-ups, too.

Boss lady still hasn't sent new work, so yesterday, in an attempt to feel productive, I went on a MEFA reading/reviewing spree. I actually managed to review 11 stories in a go, that's possibly more than I did in the past two years combined. (>_>) If I keep this up for a couple more days, I'll actually review all the pieces on my wishlist, which would be a Good Thing and make me feel all accomplished. (Even though my wishlist is reasonably short this year - 50 stories - because I assembled it with the utmost prejudice - that means I'll probably miss many good stories, but oh well, I'll hopefully also miss most of the stories that'll only piss me off anyway - with only a few "this premise sounded too interesting to miss" surprises thrown in. And the one single piece of Roverandom fanfiction! <3)
As ever, I am fascinated by some of the genres that appear to be really, really, really popular in the fandom. I don't get them at all. Legolas hurt/comfort, for instance. Yawn. But then other people in the fandom surely don't get my obsession with the Sons of Fëanor, or Númenor, so all's well. Takes all kinds to make a world, even in subcreation-subcreation. I'm just fascinated that some people are capable of moving in all of them! But that's just my prejudice.
While sorting through the many nominations, I encountered a hilarious warning. I am skeptical about warnings on stories because they tend to be overused and I sometimes facepalm at the things people feel the need to warn about* - but there was one story where the warnings made me laugh out loud. It went:
Warning: Flagrant disregard for canon. Egregious librarian abuse. Plagiarism -- both alone and with someone else.(1) Rated PG.
The story as such seems to be not my thing - not my characters, not my genre - but I'm tempted to read it anyway just because the warning is so awesome.
(The footnote, possibly the most delicious detail, references the origin of the Plagiarism -- both alone and with someone else line. Which is really the most awesome thing ever. In this year, anyway, and if you're German or familiar with German politics in particular. Well, and I guess you'd need to be familiar with confessional formulae, too. Oh, gods, context. Why did I leave academia again?)

The bees, alas, were stupid. When you unite two hives, you're supposed to brush all the bees of the weaker hive in front of the box of the stronger hive so they have to find their way in on their own - that way, the queen (or any laying workers) are stopped and killed by the guard bees and there won't be any war or regicide going on inside the old hive. Anyway, the point is you can't just put the frames of the old hive into the other.
My boxes are placed on a wooden palette so they have even footing, and also so that, should there be a lot of snow (as there was in the past years) fresh air can still find its way into the hive from below. So there's a height difference between the ground and the entrance of the hive. For which reason I built a ramp from the lid of the now-empty box (the ground as such would've been too cold for the bees at this time of year). That's what they tell you to do in the bee-keeping courses, too. Foolproof, they say. Works every time. Bees are smart.
Yeah. Guess what the bees did?
Instead of marching into the hive, they balled up underneath the ramp. Where, of course, a goodly amount of them froze. Fortunately, only the outer layers - inside the ball they were still warm and alive.
So I took the ramp away and instead balanced a board right in front of the entrance, and then brushed the bees onto that board, and then most of them made it into the hive before it started sleeting. *facepalms*
(Yes, it's late in the year to unite hives, but as November was so mild, it wasn't clear then whether it would actually be necessary -- I had to wait for colder temperatures. Unfortunately, we didn't get dry cold but wet cold...)

While dealing with the bees, I had to leave Felix alone, inside, in his cot - of course. (That is, I couldn't take him along to the bees, of course - and I had to leave him alone because there was no daddy or mom-in-law or other babysitter available during daylight. It was only twenty minutes anway.). By the time I came back he was screaming in panic, and he was crying so hard that the tears were pooling in his ears. I have no idea how people can still propagate leaving babies (even younger than Felix is now, at that!) to cry as a measure of teaching them to be on their own and not pester their parents. In the olden days, when we didn't know all the things about heartrates and stress levels and the way the infant mind works -- but today? ARGH. (Jörg recently asked me why I was getting so worked up about what my aunt had said. This is why. Grandmothers are grandmothers, but she's of our - well, his - generation and could know better.)
Anyway, I felt like a rotten mother for the rest of the day. Felix, on the other hand, calmed down as soon as I cradled him and gave him suck and kissed the salt streaks away, and was back to his cheerful, curious, cuddly self afterwards, so I assume I have been forgiven...

Tenant lady dropped by this morning to say that the mice were back in their ceiling. >_> Hopefully it's just because we finally put the heating ducts inside as opposed to up the outside walls and haven't yet blocked all the passageways into the house (as I said, until recently it was pretty mild outside - and Jörg is back to normal work, which in December is particularly stressful because of the delightful "Whoops there goes the year" brand of planning, so construction work is only possible on Sundays), so that problem will be solved easily. Otherwise, I foresee another Week From Hell (TM) like we had in summer when I was just out of the hospital...

And that's it from Lyra-land for today, or for the moment anyway.

- - -
*[livejournal.com profile] dawn_felagund has once parodied this tendency: "Warning for sex (sometimes graphic), blood and violence, mature themes, Maedhros as the main character, Feanor hugging his kids, someone sitting in a purple chair and looking at a goldfish, dirty Kleenex in Chapter 5, Maglor being present in some of the scenes, and cheese." And yes, sometimes it really feels like that.
oloriel: (Fëanor made me take this one I swear.)


... or rather "somethings", but that's ungrammatical, so.

* The date for next year's Drachenfest has been announced and against all odds it's not at the same time as the Mittelerdefest, but a week later! I've been waiting for - and dreading - the announcement because it was pretty likely that both events would fall around the same weekend and then I'd have had to decide for just one (that is, for the MEF...). As I'm already missing this year's DF for obvious reasons, that'd have been very sad. So yay for actually being able (time-wise; anything else we'll see) to do both! \o/

* Five of my stories have been nominated for this year's MEFAs. To be sure, with the majority of them I'm pretty much certain they don't stand a chance - one might just get lucky, it's got Fingon in it and contains no overly complicated or controversial concepts, which always makes for crowd-pleasers - but it's still nice people liked them well enough to nominate them. Of course, as in past years, there are some stories where I'd secretly hoped someone would nominate them and nobody did (I tell myself that of course people loved them but didn't remember just now because they're old stuff :P), and as I despise self-nomination and fail at self-advertising, I'll just have to suck that up. Ah well. Five noms is still awesome, particularly as I've been a very unproductive fanficcer these past months.

* Today I managed to catch up with my gardening plan for the kitchen part of the garden, i.e. I managed to finish weeding all nine veggie patches and sow everything that had to be sown by June. As it's still June (if just barely), I consider this a splendid success. We'll see whether I'll manage to take care of the rest of the garden soonish, too, but there's less pressure - although all those spreading weeds are a pest, they're not interfering with anything important. Now I just have to harvest and use up the redcurrants and blackcurrants, as well as all those ripe woodland strawberries. And figure out what to do with my surplus tomato plants - this year, I actually have too many. (When you sow tomatoes, you bring out at least twice as many seeds as you want plants, because usually at least half of them won't grow anyway. This year, all of them grew, and two so powerfully that I had to take slippings, and these slippings in turn all took root, and then I got another plant from the uphill neighbour which I couldn't politely refuse, so now I have rather more plants than I bargained for -- which I guess is good, but I have to re-think my initial plans to make room for all of them.) Eh well, if they all manage to bring me ripe tomatoes, I shan't complain further!

* Am having an "actionism!" phase. Unfortunately it's neither typical nesting ("CLEAN ALL THE THINGS!") nor fannish actionism, but rather (mostly LARPish... it's that time of the year) creative stuff for which I lack the materials or skillz or both. Might nonetheless be tempted to try. At any rate, motivation is a good thing, even if it's kinda pointless motivation. Particularly if it's motivation for something other than sewing (current creative project of choice is "Pimp my cheap IKEA nursing bag!", which will result in something reasonably awesome, but my sewing finger is pretty raw by now, so I'll need a break after that). So there we go.

* Oh and I made carrot cake yesterday, with some variations from the original recipe (WTF what kind of crazy person puts ground apricot kernels into a cake? Don't those contain, like, Prussic acid?) and from my first attempt at the recipe (which was tasty enough but kinda dry). Added more baking powder, replaced apricot kernels with sweet almonds (I just trust those more, 'k?), replaced maize grits with just more "normal" flour (well, wholemeal spelt flour, but that's still more normal than maize grits :P), added chopped apple. Refused to mess around with the eggs as the recipe demanded (in the original recipe, you're supposed to separate the whites from the yolks, beat the whites, beat the yolks and mix them with all the other ingredients, then put the beaten whites back in. I assume this is supposed to make the cake fluffy or something, but as I said it was pretty dry nonetheless. So this time around I just put the eggs in whole from the start (I mean, without the shells, clearly, but whites and yolks together, yes?) because I hate separating eggs and certainly won't do it if it doesn't serve some sort of point. And I even used less eggs than the recipe called for because I only had two eggs left and our uphill neighbours' chickens had an unproductive week. AND IT WAS AWESOME. Not the least bit dry, instead sweet and fruity and juicy. Despite the spelt flour, too! Screw you, absurdly complicated recipe with your weird ingredients. I MADE YOU SIMPLER AND BETTER.

And that concludes today's random joyspam. Not a "Five things that made me happy" meme participant, but it might as well be...
oloriel: (lww - adorably geeky)


Darn, XKCD kinda beat me to the syntactic Christmas tree joke. I've been meaning to draw that one for a couple of years and always failed because I'm really bad with tree diagrams, so bad I'm not even certain I could correctly analyse "Wishing you a merry Christmas and a happy New Year" or the like. I know, shameful.
Eh well, one less project.

In cryptic news, I hate keeping secrets. One week to go, that should not be so hard, but darn, I'm BURSTING.

In fannish news, the MEFAs are over (somehow it completely passed me by that voting ended on December 15th, I totally thought it was December 20th, so now I didn't even manage to review all the stories I nominated, let alone the rest - I wrote two reviews altogether, with 75 stories on my wishlist (after three rounds of pruning, you don't want to know how many there were before that). Shameful. More embarrassing because my Opus Magnum-in-progress won first place and that sort of thing always make me feel I should have given something back. Bad fangirl, no cookie.

In artistic news, you know, gals, if you don't tell me what you want me to draw, I can't draw it, yes?

In metereologic news, no news, still snowing. So pretty, but much work.
Which reminds me of a joke [livejournal.com profile] lainvess made recently; unfortunately (for the English-speaking crowd) it only works in Fandom German:

Was tun Fangirls im Winter?
Schnee shippen...
oloriel: (canatic Fingolfin)


I’m at work, and will be for two more hours. Actually the simulator just broke down, so it seems we'll be going home now. Yay.

I haven’t properly updated this LJ in ages, and there are various things I should have written about, and meant to write about. I never got around to the first few, and then whenever something new cropped up, I thought, “No, I can’t write about this before I’ve written about…”, and so it all got postponed indefinitely.

To break that run, I will for the moment pretend that I did write all those entries I should have written in late July and all through August, and write this entry without first listing everything I should’ve said.

So I'm at work, and because work is boring and I felt uninspired, writing-wise, and can't go making up lame fandom-inside jokes (What's a Númenorean in Middle-earth? - Out of his depth. HAH!) all the time, and I have to get all those MEFA stories read at some point, I copied one of the novels I meant to read into a word document and started reading.

The story as such is all right, and quite well-written, and I am all the more peeved by the not so good bits.

The first, and this is something that annoys me tremendously, is the use of ellon and elleth where there is absolutely no need for it. I know that it is fashionable (even considered the only right way, I hear) in parts of the Tolkien fandom never never ever to call a male elf a "man" or a female elf a "woman". Nor can an elf of either sex just be "an elf". Or "somebody". Noooo, it has to be "the ellon/elleth" all the way. [Same bullshit in German fandom, btw, where you could actually get the sex across by using der Elb or die Elbin (and PLEASE, not die Elbe, even though the elfin variant would be die Elfe. Die Elbe is a river that ends in the North Sea, not any sort of pointy-eared person, damn it.)]

It drives me batty. If I happened to be writing a story about Japanese people, I wouldn't go talking about otoko no hito or onna no hito all the time, now would I?

The argument for this fashion is, apparently, that "man" or "woman" are just not pretty enough. And supposedly Tolkien neeever ever would have gone calling a male elf a "man", because that would be a male mortal.

Dude, no.
I'm too lazy to look up quotes now, but I know I could come up with a shitload that have "man" and "woman" for either Elf or mortal. A capitalised "Man" would be definitely mortal (that's why we do the funky capitalisation thing), but a "man" is any male sapient being, just as any female sapient being is a "woman", regardless of race. Use "elf-man" or "elf-woman" if you want to be precise, but go away with the bloody Sindarin*. And honestly, in a story set purely in Valinor, why bother? Especially in places where you would, in a story about humans, use "someone" or just plain "he" or "she" instead of "the man/woman". Seriously. WE ALL KNOW THEY'RE ELVES, WE DO NOT NEED TO BE REMINDED EVERY 20 WORDS. - Tolkien actually very rarely used the Elvish words, preferring - the English. GO FIGURE.

But ok, I guess it's a matter of taste. I had the story in a word document anyway, so I did some CTRL+H and voilà, the annoying ellyn and ellith disappeared.

As I said, on the whole the story is good. And at work I'm glad for all distractions. I mean, I even read that awful book with the spaaarkling vampires and the personality-free protagonists that put me off the word "chuckle" for ever and ever at work. Work is special that way.

And then there was a line that totally rubbed me the wrong way. It went like this:
"There were children playing on the docks when the Noldor slaughtered their kin at Alqualondë." And goes on about how even millennia later nobody talks about that.

Which I thought unlikely, because a) the singers would doubtlessly have had a feast day about this one, not hushed it up, and b) it doesn't even make sense within the context of the whole story.
I first meant to write a rant, but then it turned into a decadrabble. Or whatever you call a ficlet of 1,000 words.

In lieu of a rant. For the non-Tolkienists: warning for Tolkienism, skip at own leisure. For the Tolkienists: warning for blood, guts and gore, because Alqualondë is not a happy place. + overuse of the word 'those'. )


Not sure whose POV this is supposed to be. One of the sons of Fëanor, likely, but I'm not certain who. Not Celegorm or Curufin, I guess, but that still leaves five.
No idea about the context either.
Whatever.

If nothing else, that was therapeutic.

And now I go back to reading, because the story isn't bad, just choosing to annoy me a little every now and then.

This is gonna be a long Awards season.

- - -
*The story is mostly set in 4th Age Valinor, so at least it's actually possible that they'd be using Sindarin in Valinor.

Profile

oloriel: (Default)
oloriel

April 2023

S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9101112131415
161718192021 22
232425262728 29
30      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Apr. 24th, 2026 08:56 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios